-MONTHLY VHS & DVD REVIEW-
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|

Marlene Dietrich DVD collection:
Blonde Venus
Desire
Devil Is A Woman
Dishonoured
Flame Of New Orleans
Follow The Boys
A Foreign Affair
Golden Earrings
Morocco
Pittsburgh
Seven Sinners
Song Of Songs
|
|
The Devil Is A Woman
cast: Marlene Dietrich, Lionel Atwill, Edward Everett Horton, Alison Skipworth, and Cesar Romero
director: Josef Von Sternberg
79 minutes (PG) 1935
Universal Pictures DVD Region 2 retail
RATING:
8/10
reviewed by Alasdair Stuart
|
|
|
Set in the centre of a Spanish carnival, The Devil Is A Woman is a story nested
within a story. Captain Donald Pasqual (Lionel Atwill), makes the acquaintance of Antonio
Galvan (Cesar Romero). Against the backdrop of the local carnival, Pasqual attempts to warn
the younger man of the horrors of romance by recanting the story of his tempestuous love
affair with Concha Perez (Marlene Dietrich).
What makes The Devil Is A Woman work is its narrative structure. As the experienced
older man tells the story of his life against the surrealist carnival backdrop, the present
day sequences sit somewhere between Carnival Of Souls and Chaucer, and Atwill
is excellent here, combining tremendous authority with the sort of tired devotion that really
marks the romance out as something different. This is a man whose love for a woman has been
ruined by his life, and yet he can't walk away from her. It's a traditional take on the romance
story, the self-destructive relationship that refuses to die, but the performance and the
restrictions of the time make this work with an unusual delicacy and poignancy.

Needless to say, Dietrich is on top form as Perez. Here she's an almost static role, an ideal
that both men aspire to and yet neither truly want. In many ways a script element rather than
a character she still manages to give depth to the role and her intelligence, and occasional
malice, go a long way towards explaining why Pasqual is so obsessed and doomed by his love
for her.
Playing out in the present tense and with an ending, which is unusually narratively daring,
The Devil Is A Woman is an old fashioned romance that has lost none of its bite for
that. The superb costumes, unusual structure and well observed characters work as well now
as they did then. Recommended.
|
|