-MONTHLY VHS & DVD REVIEW-
|
|
|
|
|
|
copyright © 2001 - 2005 VideoVista
|
|
|
|
Valdez Horses
cast: Charles Bronson, Jill Ireland, and Marcel Bozzuff
director: John Sturges, Dulio Coletti
93 minutes (15) 1974
widescreen ratio 16:9
Momentum DVD Region 2 retail
RATING:
7/10
reviewed by John Percival
|
|
|
Valdez Horses is a thoughtful western with Charles Bronson at his most brooding.
Here as loner Chino Valdez, a half Indian and half Mexican, he faces enough problems
but always seems most comfortable on his remote ranch and in the company of the horses
he breaks in. However his life changes with the arrival of a 15-year-old runaway and
falling in love with a vicious landowner's sister.
Not really being used to westerns I gave this one a try because even though I had not
heard of it before, the combination of Charles Bronson and Jill Ireland usually produces
good results. I am glad to say that even though the story is simple and the pace slow,
essentially it is quite enjoyable.
Although there are moments of action it is not really what defines this movie and much
of the emphasis is on the interactions between Chino and the other characters. Chino
is generally tough and brooding usually involved in fights in the local town, he withdraws
to his ranch to break in horses and they are what he respects. It is surprising then
that not only does he take in the runaway and teach him the way of life, that also he
swings from politely insulting the posh Catherine to falling in love with her. Some
of the problems for Chino result from his half-Indian background. The racists from
town use that as excuse to attack him, although Chino does give as good as he gets.
Also even though he is a loner he still has connections to an Indian tribe and returns
there frequently, giving Jamie a lesson in other cultures. It is also to them that Jamie
takes Chino when he is badly injured by Marcel the neighbour who is trying to steal
Chino's land and drive him away from his sister.
It is the relationship and near marriage of Chino and Catherine that leads the cowboy
to crisis. Nearly killed by Marcel's men he does not return as an angry 'angel of vengeance'
all hot lead and chewing tobacco. With Catherine out of his reach, he defends himself
against the men who continue to hunt him before he sets his horses free and torches
the ranch. He and Jamie then ride off into the distance.
It is definitely an unusual ending, as it seems that the bad guy has won and nothing
has been resolved. I can see how some people would find this unsatisfying that after
the slow story we are denied the hero's victory. However maybe that is the point that
the hero does not always win the big battles but also withdrawing from the conflict
prevents any further casualties such as Jamie or Catherine can be the better option.
The filming is really quite good and with the stunning scenery everything appears to
be thoughtfully appropriate and not stereotypical. There are many elements that are
interesting to watch, such as the respectful way that the horses are broken in. Also
the growing relationship between Jamie and Chino as Chino gradually becomes fonder of
the boy who represents the child he has never had. Chino is obviously a man with a sad
and troubled past, from the scars on his body, his own exile to the doomed relationship
with Catherine, Bronson draws out each element brilliantly. He is not an angry gun-slinging
thug but a thoughtful troubled man with good intentions. For anyone looking for a different
kind of western then this would be a good choice. For someone who usually shies away
from westerns I am really quite glad to have seen this one.
|
|